| |
A
little bit of love in the middle ages
by Lady Eden Blacksmith
"Sweet lover come,
renew our lovemaking within the garden where the light birds sing, until
the watcher sound the severing. Ah God, ah God, the dawn! It comes how
soon."
The Middle Ages Volume I
Love: the intangible element,
was a factor in the Middle Ages; however, its definition by society was
defined by the time period. Our forefathers and foremothers loved well
and long, and much poetry and literature is given to the many aspects of
loving. Indeed, for many centuries -from the time of the Greeks through
the seventeenth century - physicians regularly offered treatment for love-sickness,
"the lovers malady of heroes," which they regarded as both a physical and
a mental affliction.
To better understand the
supposed relationship between the sexes it is important that you know prior
to 1174 women were told:
"You are the devil's
gateway...you are the first deserter of the divine law; you are she who
persuaded him whom the devil was not valiant enough to attack. You destroyed
so easily God's image, man. On account of your desert- that is, death-
even the Son of God had to die."
Typical themes in medieval writings
are: women have unbridled passions, inability to keep secrets, weakness
for flattery, greed, extravagant dress, pride, duplicity, and shrewish-ness.
Sex even within marriage is a sin, women are the source of sin and mortality
due to Eve, and woman should be punished throughout her life for the failings
of Eve. Only slightly tempered by the concept of courtly love.
In 1174, Andreas Capellanus,
chaplain to Marie de France, gave the world; The Art of Courtly Love. It
is now believed that he was not trying to write a serious code of conduct;
instead he was trying to have a bit of fun. Courtly love required adherence
to rules elaborated in the songs of the troubadours between the 11th
and the 13th centuries. A nobleman in love with a married woman
of equally high or higher birth had to prove his devotion by heroic deeds
and amorous writings. Once the lovers had exchanged pledges and consummated
their passion, complete secrecy had to be maintained. Because most noble
marriages of the time were little more than business contracts, courtly
love was a form of sanctioned adultery. Capellanus said: ". . . a certain
inborn suffering derived from the sight of and excessive meditation upon
the beauty of the opposite sex, which causes each one to wish above all
things the embraces of the other and by common desire to carry out all
of love's precepts in the other's embrace."
The concept of "pure love"
which included strongly self-deprecating behavior and servitude by a man
for a distant, unattainable woman was a driving force throughout the high
period of medieval love literature. From 1100 to 1300 (most intensely in
the quarter-centuries before and after 1200), the language of lady love
prevailed in the courts of England and Europe. The concept that women should
be admired was vastly different from the misogynist writings that flourished
at that time. The sin, guilt and impurities of women were being preached
from every pulpit. This new position that a woman was to be worshiped and
idolized gave women a new power and a new version of enslavement. For if
in this "game" of love the truth was learned, then it was the woman that
was punished. Her virtue was a great conquest and her value would only
last as long as she was prey. If she were to yield and their tryst discovered
than she was seen as the weak, wanton creature that the Church said, and
the man was viewed with the admiration that any victor would receive.
The art of Courtly Love had
very clear, but conflicting rules: A man who is vexed by too much passion
usually does not love, yet, a true lover is constantly and without intermission
possessed by the thought of his beloved. And love is always a stranger
in the home of avarice (jealousy), yet, jealousy, and therefore love, are
increased when one suspects his beloved. There are 31 rules listed in this
game of love. It was devised in such a way that almost no man could win
if called in to a 'Court of Love'. However, what was to be a game soon
became a societal viewpoint. The role of women and the conceptions of love
have been altered ever since.
Another publication can lay
some claim to modifying the aspects of love: Romance of the Rose (Le
Roman de la Rose), a long thirteenth-century French poem, extremely
popular and influential in the Middle Ages, was written by two authors.
The first part, 4,058 lines by Guillaume de Lorris, is a dream-vision allegory
in which an aristocratic young man falls in love with a rosebud, symbolizing
a lady or her sexual favors. The Lover is aided by a personification called
"Fair Welcome" but opposed by other personifications that symbolize the
personal and social restraints standing against his advances. Fear, Shame,
Gossip ("Malebouche" in French; "Wikked Tongue" in a Middle English translation),
and "Daunger," our word danger, which, personified as a churl wielding
a club, here representing instinctive female resistance to male sexual
desire. The first part was never finished; it breaks off with the rose
imprisoned in the castle of Jealousy with the Lover disconsolate on the
outside.
Jean de Meun, an academic
at the University of Paris, who continued it for another 17,724 lines,
which cover religion, philosophy, history, science, sex, love, marriage,
and women, took up the poem. From its teachings women were told: There
is also a proper way to weep, but every woman has the skill to weep properly
wherever she may be. Even when no one has caused them any trouble or shame
or annoyance, they still have tears at the ready: they all weep in whatever
they like, and make a habit of it. And we learn that, in short, [men] are
all deceitful traitors, ready to indulge their lusts with everyone, and
we should deceive them in our turn and not set our hearts upon just one
of them. It is a foolish woman who gives her heart in this way. She ought
to have several lovers and arrange, if she can, to be so pleasing that
she brings great suffering upon all of them. If she has no graces, let
her acquire them and always behave more cruelly towards those who will
strive all the harder to serve her in order to win her love, while exerting
herself to welcome those who do not care about it.
Our ancestors enjoyed a good
love story as much as we do. And, no other love story fulfills this inclination
than that of Abelard and Heloise. It contains passion, forbidden love,
forbidden sex, unwed-pregnancy, torture, imprisonment, longing, unrequited
love, of resentment and castration.. This is a summary of their story;
Pierre Abelard (1079-1142), who was by all accounts a brilliant scholar
and theologian, met Heloise (1101-1164) 22 years his junior and soon was
smitten with her...
"Take thou this rose,
O rose, Since love's own flower it is, And by that rose Thy lover captive
is." --Abelard
...and had prevailed upon her
Uncle Fulbert, a Canon of the Cathedral, to become her private teacher.
"We were united first
in the dwelling that sheltered our love, and then in the hearts that burned
with it. Under the pretext of study we spent our hours in the happiness
of love, and learning held out to us the secret opportunities that our
passion craved. Our speech was more of love than of the books which lay
open before us; our kisses far outnumbered our reasoned words. The very
sundering of our bodies served but to link our souls closer together; the
plentitude of the love which was denied to us inflamed us more than ever."--Abelard
The Uncle found out, Heloise
found she was pregnant, Abelard married her, the Uncle found them and brought
her back, then she had a boy named Astrolabe. Abeland and Heloise wanted
to keep the marriage secret, so Abeland and Heloise ran off. Heloise hid
in an abbey as a nun, the Uncle showed up thought she was forced to take
the veil so he had Abelard castrated.
"...for they cut
off those parts of my body with which I had done that which was the cause
of their sorrow." --Abelard
Then Abelard and Heloise both
took holy orders. Their love, far from fading, intensified. Abelard founded
a convent. He called it "Consoling Spirit". Later, Heloise became the Abbess.
Heloise wrote him long love letters and love poems and they were published
in the Historia Calamitatum so that all could read them.. These missives
of love and longing lasted for years with him begging her to stop writing
and her writing more, and him writing her to say sweet words and her writing
more, then he would write--no we must not.
"Peace, O my stricken
lute! Thy strings are sleeping.., would that my heart could still, Its
bitter weeping!" --Abelard
Upon his death Heloise had Abelard's
body brought to the Paraclete, where she was later buried beside him. They
lie together still. This medieval soap opera kept upper nobility on the
edge of their seats for years. Love in the medieval world was as complex
as it is today. Yet, perhaps it was even more so, because in a short span
of time love was defined by a new set of rules in a game we are still playing.
About Author
Sonja Borough (SCA Lady Eden Blacksmith lives in Kingman, AZ with her loving and understanding husband. She brew up in the restaurant business and has been cooking professionally for over 20 years. She now works on Ebay putting up auctions. For the past 10 years she has been studying the more sensual side of medieval life. You can reach her at edenblacksmith@usa.net.
|